Merchant Of Venice Justice And Mercy Essay

A Comparison of Justice in The Tempest and Merchant of Venice

738 Words3 Pages

Justice in The Tempest and Merchant of Venice

 

In both Merchant of Venice and The Tempest, Shakespeare proposes ideas of justice and mercy that hold true in both plays. In order to see if the actions taken were just and/or merciful, definitions of these words must be set up. If we were to assume that Shakespeare's definition of mercy was what Portia espoused in act four, scene one, specifically lines 205 - 206, the definition of mercy must be viewed in a biblical sense. Thus, in order to judge if something is merciful, one must look to see if it fulfills the qualifications of mercy in the New Testament. However, the idea of justice is quite different, for my definition of justice, I will turn to Charles Mill's definition, for,…show more content…

During the trial, it would be fair to say that mercy was given to Antonio and not Shylock. For Antonio, the other cheek was turned and he was able to be spared the loss of his life -- even though he had entered into a contract in which he put this on the line. On the other hand, money was not given to Shylock who not only was not reimbursed the money that he lent out, but he was also harmed by being forced to convert. However, when looking at why mercy was given to one and not the other, we must look at how justice was applied. In Antonio's case, he is a Catholic merchant from Europe, unlike the prince of Morocco. However, even though Shylock was also a European, he was not a Christian -- justice did not apply. However, in context, was justice served? Of course it was served, for not only was the spirit of it upheld but it was also carried out how it was meant to be carried out. Thus, in The Merchant of Venice, justice and mercy intermingle providing mercy only to the people that receive justice.

 

In The Tempest, Shakespeare again uses the concepts of justice and mercy in order to have his audience think about what just and merciful actions were taken. At the end of the play, when Prospero releases Caliban from his bondage, this action, by definition, is merciful, but in no way is it just. By releasing Caliban from his control, Prospero has taken a love thy neighbor as yourself mentality and, this, is merciful. However, when determining if

Show More

When discussing the matters of the law, one must accept what is written in the law books which are accepted by the people or rulers of the country. Laws are written in order to protect people from harm or unfairness. "Justice" is a word that connotes strength and fairness while "Mercy" seems to present itself as a weak idea reserved for victims. Justice is an idea that people call for when they feel they have been treated unfairly and want the law to fix the problems between two factions. Mercy is a gift of forgiveness not truly understood or given easily. Along these lines of thinking enters Shylock who demands justice but is asked to give mercy. Christianity and Judaism also clash in the debate as to what should hold stronger under Antonio's unfortunate circumstances.The irony comes in when a person who thinks that the law is on his side forgets mercy and demands justice. Justice systems would lose the trust of the people if it handed out mercy all of the time. Thus, when Shylock refuses to accept anything other than Antonio's pound of flesh, Portia says, "A pound of that same merchant's flesh is thine;/ The court awards it, and the law doth give it"(IV.i.307-308).

The only way that justice can be satisfied is if payment for any contract is paid. Luckily, Justice doesn't care who pays the debt, only that the contract is fulfilled. This is why Portia gave Bassanio permission to offer 6,000 ducats! She thought that any man would be willing to accept double the contract and release Antonio from the contract. Only if Shylock had dropped the case could the law back away from executing itself.

Sadly, Shylock was blind-sided by a law that he didn't know about which turns the tide against him and forces him into a position of asking for mercy. If Venitian law had not demanded that no blood should be shed, then Shylock would have had his justified way. The only two ways that Justice can be satisfied is if the contract is paid or if the petitioner drops the charges. Justice is blind for equality's sake, but Mercy is subjective and dependant upon the choice of one who would sacrifice something valuable for someone else who is trapped or has nothing of value. Mercy can only overcome Justice when it is freely given by a person's choice. Justice has claim over all who must obey the law.

0 thoughts on “Merchant Of Venice Justice And Mercy Essay”

    -->

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *